Buying a business in Canada: what it takes to reach provincial nomination
At a Circle Practice Briefing, Slava Apel (CanadaRBI) explained how he assesses whether buying a Canadian business could support a provincial nomination for permanent residence. Stan Shadrin, an independent tax consultant working with CanadaRBI, showed how tax planning can change the deal.
Slava Apel
- Canada
Key takeaways
- The federal start-up route is closed to new clients; provincial streams are not. Slava Apel (CanadaRBI) now works with entrepreneurs who are ready to move and run a business through provincial streams, decided in two to three years in his practice.
- Start with the client's business experience. Past experience as an owner or manager is the minimum Slava Apel looks for, and it decides which businesses the client could credibly run in Canada.
- Check the provincial stream before committing to a purchase. Each province sets its own rules on acquisitions, the operating period and reporting after nomination.
- Agree early who will run the business, and check the whole family. Both cases Slava Apel lost in more than ten years failed on people, not paperwork or business.
- Bring tax into the letter of intent. Stan Shadrin has seen badly built structures reach a combined tax burden of 70% and even 80%; planned before the deal, much of that burden can be legally reduced.
Americas
Canada
Slava Apel, CEO of the Toronto-based CanadaRBI, has more than 20 years of experience in Canadian business immigration. For about a decade his firm was built around the federal Start-Up Visa, and he has supported hundreds of businesses through it.
Where the federal pause leaves entrepreneurs. The fastest Start-Up Visa case Slava Apel has seen, about ten years ago, reached permanent residence in 41 days. As applications grew and processing capacity did not, decisions stretched to two or three years, then three to five, and towards the end close to ten. By his account, more than 40,000 people are still waiting. Files where the business already operates in Canada or has received investment can be prioritised. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada stopped accepting most new Start-Up Visa applications at the end of 2025; the exception for applicants with a valid 2025 commitment certificate ended on 30 June 2026. Federal notice on entrepreneur immigration and Start-Up Visa Program status
For clients who still think in start-up terms, his advice is to open or buy a business in a participating province instead. The rules are similar. The difference is that the Start-Up Visa could be started from abroad, while a provincial stream needs the client in Canada, operating the business.
Who can apply. Slava Apel said no nationality is excluded. In one month he helped forty families from Iran land in Canada, and many of his clients come from the former Soviet Union, including people refused by Caribbean programmes because they were born in Russia. A criminal record more than five years old may still be considered. About half his clients today are Americans. The limit is experience: a student, a homemaker or a teacher who has never managed anything will struggle to show a province that they can run a business.
Match the business to the operator. At the first interview he asks what the client owned or managed, how they made their money, what their parents did and how hands-on they want to be. A client from Ghana who traded medical products bought a vitamin franchise. A metals trader was matched with a metal-recycling business. A former banker, hard to place in finance, chose a fast-food franchise. For clients who want the immigration result more than a new career, he prefers franchises: few of them fail, and a franchise keeps its value if the owner later sells. Undecided clients are shown options from CanadaRBI's own database of businesses for sale, including thousands of off-market listings.
Work through the nomination conditions before the deal. Slava Apel outlined the sequence. The business is chosen and the proposal approved by the province while the client is still abroad. Provincial approval supports a work permit. The client then moves, invests and runs the business, in his experience for six to eighteen months depending on the province, before nomination opens the federal application for permanent residence. Once that commitment is met, he said, selling or closing the business does not affect permanent residence.
The provincial guides show why the choice of stream matters. Alberta's Rural Entrepreneur Stream can accept an eligible acquisition; under its Business Performance Agreement, candidates ordinarily operate for at least 12 months before submitting a final report, and Alberta also asks for a progress report after nomination. British Columbia's Regional stream requires a new business aligned with the referring community's priorities. Alberta process, Alberta post-nomination requirements, British Columbia streams and federal application process
When the route needs another passport first. One client, a doctor who had lived in the United States for twenty years, held an expired passport from a country whose embassy there had closed, and had no way to regularise his status. CanadaRBI first arranged a second citizenship through a citizenship by investment programme. With a valid new passport he could apply to Canada, where he plans to open a rehabilitation clinic.
Where cases fail. Slava Apel counts two lost cases in more than ten years. Four co-founders of one Start-Up Visa business fell out, partly over who would move first, and his team could not bring them back together. In the other, a client's young daughter was found to have a heart condition, and the family could not pass the medical examination. Group applications carry a further risk: when one member of a four-family group later acquired a criminal record, the group had to be restructured and that member's case slowed until the record no longer counted. Before partners commit, it is worth asking who will actually be in Canada running the business, and when.
Bring tax into the letter of intent. Stan Shadrin, a Chartered Professional Accountant and independent tax consultant working with CanadaRBI, has more than 20 years of experience with international and Canadian accounting firms, working for clients from high-net-worth individuals to public companies on tax structuring and on mergers and acquisitions. Canada's tax system, enacted in 1917 and reformed in 1971, has never fully caught up with modern business, he said, which leaves room both for planning and for traps. He has seen structures where the combined tax burden reached 70% and even 80%, but he was clear that this outcome is not inevitable: with professional tax planning before the move, much of that exposure can be legally reduced, and in many cases avoided. His work goes beyond a review: he assesses the client's full position across every jurisdiction involved and builds a clear tax plan before the move, which is why he treats it as the first step of any relocation, not an afterthought. He wants a tax adviser involved while the letter of intent is drafted, and in some deals has asked for restructuring before it goes out. Tax findings shape which shares are bought, whether a holding company is used and how money from foreign companies, trusts, foundations or partnerships is brought in. For some buyers the deal matters more than an extra C$100,000 in tax, and a simple structure is the right answer.
For entrepreneurs who keep businesses, investments or royalties abroad, he looks at what reaches the owner personally after tax in every jurisdiction involved. Australian advisers once built a client an excellent Australian structure, but drawing money from it into Canada produced a combined burden above 70%. Another client, with businesses in countries with and without a tax treaty with Canada, planned distributions before moving and paid no Canadian tax over five years. Neither result can be promised in advance, he said; each depends on the client's facts.
Working with agents. CanadaRBI works only through referring firms, and the referring adviser remains the client's point of contact. Slava Apel's team handles the business search and the business case, which he estimates at 99% of the work: a file of more than a thousand pages with projections, a hiring plan and the expected local economic impact. An authorised Canadian immigration representative handles the regulated immigration advice and files the application. Federal guidance on paid representatives
Questions from the room
Can clients still apply for a Start-Up Visa, and what should existing applicants expect? New applications are not accepted, and existing files face long waits, said Slava Apel. For a prospective applicant prepared to run a business in Canada, he suggested assessing a provincial entrepreneur stream, decided in two to three years rather than up to ten.
Should a buyer acquire a restaurant's assets or the company that owns it? Stan Shadrin said Canadian sellers are often keen to sell shares because the lifetime capital gains exemption, which he put at about C$1.25 million per seller, can shelter much of the gain, and they may accept a lower price for it. In a cash business he would look closely at how sales were reported and whether there had been tax audits. If the building is included, he would usually hold it in a separate real estate company, out of reach of the operating business's risks. In larger deals, known tax risks can be isolated through restructuring before the sale or covered by tax insurance. Canada Revenue Agency guidance on acquisitions and capital gains deduction
Which other routes can advisers assess? More than ten, said Slava Apel. Express Entry suits young skilled workers with strong English or French, many of whom need no adviser at all. Provincial streams cover particular occupations, and rural community programmes offer permanent residence to people ready to live and work in small towns. Business streams serve a different client: over forty, or with weaker English, and scoring too low for anything else. Federal overview of immigration routes
Can an investor finance the required investment? Slava Apel described bank-financed investments he had seen under Quebec's Investor Program. The province's published conditions require an agreement with an authorised intermediary, a specified level of spoken French and a stay in Quebec. For other business streams, he added, the client must show their own funds, though money given or lent by family can count if the transfer is documented. Quebec Investor Program conditions
What it means for practice
Before a client commits to a purchase, check whether the business fits their experience, what the chosen province requires before and after nomination, and how the ownership structure will affect their tax position after the move. Bring the business, immigration and tax advisers in while the terms can still change.
From the meeting
Practice Briefing: Canada's regional business immigration: from business investment to provincial nomination, 18 November 2026.
About the meetingThis recap is general information, not legal, tax or immigration advice. The views are the participants' own.